Is chocolate healthy? Here’s what the science says

What you’ll learn:

• Dark chocolate is a healthier choice due to its higher cocoa content, rich antioxidants, and lower sugar levels.
• Studies link it to improved mood, weight management, and cardiovascular health, but its calorie density makes portion control essential.
• Opting for high-quality dark chocolate with minimal additives over heavily processed chocolate-flavored products helps maximize its health benefits.

Chocolate is often seen as an indulgence, but what if it could also be a smart choice? Science suggests that dark chocolate, in particular, offers more than just a rich, satisfying taste. We know now that it’s packed with antioxidants and essential minerals linked to heart health, a better mood, and even weight management.

But before you grab just any chocolate bar, here’s the catch: Some types of chocolate bring more to the table than others. Milk and white chocolate tend to be higher in sugar and contain fewer beneficial compounds, making them more of a treat than a health booster. And while dark chocolate has its perks, it’s still calorie-dense, so a little mindfulness goes a long way.

So, what makes dark chocolate the standout choice? It all comes down to cocoa content. The higher the percentage, the more antioxidants and the less sugar it contains. Research suggests that cocoa flavanols may help improve circulation, reduce inflammation, and even give your brain a little boost.

With countless chocolate options available, you need to know what to look for when choosing one that aligns with your health goals. Let’s explore what science says about chocolate’s benefits (and drawbacks) and how to enjoy it mindfully.

How is chocolate made, and what makes it unique?

Chocolate starts its journey—much like coffee does—as a bean on a tree. The process of making chocolate begins with harvesting the beans from the cacao pods of the tree. These beans are then fermented, dried, and roasted. The “nibs” are harvested and ground into a thick liquid called chocolate liquor containing cocoa solids and cocoa butter. At this point, sugar, milk, or cocoa butter are added depending on the type of chocolate. 

Beyond its rich taste and luxurious texture, chocolate is special because of its unique combination of antioxidants and minerals.  It contains magnesium, iron, potassium, and small amounts of theobromine (a compound offering mild stimulant effects) and caffeine, which can provide a gentle energy boost. Dark chocolate, in particular, is known for its high cocoa content and lower sugar levels, making it more nutrient-dense than milk or white chocolate.

From bean to bar, chocolate results from a carefully crafted process that creates a delicious treat and potential health benefits when enjoyed in moderation.

What is the nutritional info and calorie count for dark chocolate?

The calorie count of dark chocolate and nutrient density will depend on the percentage. Here’s a quick look at the nutritional breakdown of one ounce of 70-85% dark chocolate:

• Calories: 170 calories 
• Fat: 12.1 g
• Carbohydrates: 13 g (sugar: 6.8 g)
• Protein: 2.21 g

Other nutrients:

• Fiber: 3 g (12% RDA* for women, 8% RDA for men)
• Iron: 3.37 mg (19% RDA for women, 42% RDA for men)
• Magnesium: 64 mg (21% RDA for women, 15% RDA for men)
• Potassium: 203 mg (8% RDA for women, 6% RDA for men)
• Theobromine: 227 mg 
• Caffeine: 22 mg (an 8-ounce cup of coffee has 80–100 mg of caffeine).

*Recommended dietary allowance (RDA) is defined as the average daily amount of nutrients that are needed to meet the requirements of nearly all healthy people in a specific group.

What do dark chocolate percentages mean?

Dark chocolate comes in different cocoa percentages, which indicate how much of the bar is made up of cocoa solids and cocoa butter compared to other ingredients like sugar. A bar with 85% cocoa contains more cocoa solids and cocoa butter, making it richer in antioxidants and lower in sugar than one with 60% cocoa. Be aware, though, that the higher the percentage, the more bitter the flavor. Here’s a breakdown:

• 50%: Half of this chocolate bar is made up of cocoa solids and cocoa butter, while the other 50% includes sugar and sometimes small amounts of milk or flavorings. This dark chocolate is typically sweeter and closer to milk chocolate in flavor.
• 70%: The bar consists of 70% cocoa solids and cocoa butter, while the remaining 30% is sugar and other ingredients. The flavor is usually a nice balance between bitterness and sweetness.
• 85%: The bar contains 85% cocoa, leaving just 15% sugar and other additives. It will typically have an intense, less sweet flavor.
• 90%: With 90% cacao content, this chocolate is extremely rich in cocoa solids and cocoa butter and contains very little sugar. It will have the most bitter flavor and the least sweetness.

What about chocolate without percentages?

• Semi-sweet (typically 55-60% cocoa): Semi-sweet chocolate contains a moderate amount of sugar while still retaining a noticeable cocoa flavor. It’s commonly used in baking, particularly in chocolate chip cookies and other desserts.
• Bittersweet (typically 65-80% cocoa): This variety contains a higher percentage of cocoa solids and less sugar than semisweet chocolate, but it still has some sweetness to balance the bitterness. Bittersweet chocolate is also commonly used in baking.
• Unsweetened (100% cocoa): Made entirely of cocoa solids and cocoa butter, with no added sugar, unsweetened chocolate is the most bitter form of chocolate. It is not meant for snacking but is often used in baking, where sugar and other ingredients are included to balance its intensity. Due to its pure cocoa content, it offers the highest antioxidant levels of any chocolate.

How does dark chocolate differ from milk and white chocolate?

The differences between dark, milk, and white chocolate go beyond flavor—they also vary in cocoa content, nutrient density, and potential health benefits. Dark chocolate delivers a more potent antioxidant boost than milk or white chocolate due to its higher cocoa content. Here’s a breakdown of some other important differences:

• Dark chocolate: Contains at least 50-90% cocoa solids and cocoa butter. It’s the most nutrient-dense option, richer in antioxidants and minerals. Dark chocolate (70-85%), while slightly higher in calories and fat than milk and white chocolate, has less than half the sugar. It is also higher in fiber, iron, protein, and potassium.
• Milk chocolate: Has a lower cocoa content (10-50%) and contains more sugar, milk, and additives, which reduces its antioxidant content. It has the highest carbohydrates and lowest calories of the three types by a small margin but falls between dark chocolate and white chocolate on most other values.
• White chocolate: Contains no cocoa solids and is primarily made of cocoa butter, sugar, and milk. It has the highest cholesterol and sodium but also has the highest calcium.

If you’re looking for a sweet treat with added health benefits, dark chocolate is the winner. However, if you’re a fan of milk or white chocolate, everything is okay in moderation!

What is blonde and ruby chocolate?

Blonde and ruby chocolates are newer varieties that stand out in flavor, what they’re made from (types of cacao beans and other ingredients like cocoa solids), and appearance.

• Blonde chocolate, sometimes called caramelized white chocolate, is made by slowly heating white chocolate to caramelize the sugars and milk solids. This process gives it a golden color and a sweet, toffee-like flavor. Unlike dark chocolate, blonde chocolate doesn’t contain cocoa solids—it’s made from cocoa butter, sugar, and milk—which means it lacks the antioxidants and nutrients found in milk or dark chocolate.
• Ruby chocolate, on the other hand, is made from specially processed “ruby cocoa beans” that give it a natural pinkish-red hue and a fruity, berry-like flavor. While it contains cocoa solids, it’s sweeter and less bitter than dark chocolate and contains fewer nutrients. 

The biggest difference? Dark chocolate is rich in cocoa solids, giving it its bold flavor and making it richer in fiber and antioxidants and lower in sugar. On the other hand, blonde and ruby chocolates focus more on unique flavors and aesthetics. They’re fun and delicious options, but they don’t offer the same nutrient profile as dark chocolate.

What about “chocolate-flavored” products?

Products without cocoa solids, like some “chocolate-flavored” candies or coatings, aren’t technically chocolate. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has strict standards for what can legally be labeled as chocolate, including specific minimum percentages of cocoa solids and cocoa butter for different types. Products that don’t meet these requirements may be labeled “chocolate-flavored” or “made with chocolate” instead, so keep an eye out for these words on the packaging. 

These products typically lack the nutrients and antioxidants that make chocolate beneficial. Instead, they’re often made from sugar, vegetable oils, artificial flavorings, and milk solids, offering little to no health benefits. Some examples include chocolate-flavored syrups, candy coatings found on some non-premium chocolate bars, and chocolate-flavored spreads without a high cocoa content.

Is chocolate good for weight loss? The science

Despite the fact that chocolate is a high caloric density food, some studies do show that, in moderation, it can help with weight management and reduce cravings.

A small study on milk chocolate found that eating nearly 3.5 ounces of it in the morning did not lead to weight gain in the short term in postmenopausal women. Morning chocolate consumption was linked to reduced hunger and sweet cravings, reduced waist circumference, and increased fat burning. However, given the small size and scope of this study, more research is needed in order to validate these claims. Sign us up!

Dark chocolate might be even more powerful. Its flavonoids and polyphenols may reduce inflammation, a factor sometimes linked to weight gain. Dark chocolate can also help with feelings of fullness. In one study, men who ate dark chocolate felt more satisfied and ate 17% less at their next meal than those who had milk chocolate. 

The potential health benefits of eating chocolate

Beyond its rich flavor and effect on satiety, chocolate also contains compounds and nutrients that may provide notable health benefits, including:

• Supporting heart health: Flavonoids, plant pigments found in many fruits, vegetables, and other foods like dark chocolate, may improve blood flow and lower blood pressure, benefiting cardiovascular health.
• Sharpening focus: The flavanols found in cocoa could provide a quick mental lift, potentially improving memory and reaction time, though more consistent evidence is needed.
• Boosting mood: Chocolate may improve mood. A 2022 study found that daily consumption of 85% cocoa dark chocolate reduced negative feelings in healthy adults, possibly due to beneficial changes in gut microbiota.  

These benefits are still being studied, and more research is needed to validate them.

The drawbacks of chocolate

Even dark chocolate, despite its higher nutrient density, can cause issues if consumed in excess. Here are some of the common downsides of chocolate:

• High in calories: All types of chocolate are high in calories and contain refined sugar and minimal fiber. Excess calorie intake from any source is associated with weight gain.
• Could cause digestive discomfort: For some, chocolate can cause acid reflux or digestive issues.

Is chocolate an ultra-processed food?

Chocolate is often categorized as an ultra-processed food (UPF) due to its manufacturing process and added ingredients, but this classification isn’t always accurate—especially for high-quality dark chocolate.

The level of processing varies widely depending on the type of chocolate. While milk chocolate and white chocolate often contain high amounts of added sugar, emulsifiers, and milk solids, dark chocolate—especially varieties with minimal ingredients and high cocoa content (70% or more)—undergoes relatively simple processing and retains more of its natural nutrients. 

A 2023 study challenges the assumption that all chocolate is ultra-processed, noting that traditional chocolate-making involves natural steps like fermentation, drying, roasting, and grinding cacao beans—which are not the hallmarks of industrial food processing. Unlike many ultra-processed foods that contain chemically modified ingredients, high-quality dark chocolate can be made with as few as three ingredients: cocoa mass, cocoa butter, and a small amount of sugar. The key to determining whether chocolate falls into the ultra-processed category lies in its ingredient list—the fewer additives, artificial flavors, and preservatives, the more it aligns with whole or minimally processed foods. So, while heavily processed chocolate products like candy bars and chocolate-flavored coatings may fit the UPF label, a high-cocoa, low-sugar dark chocolate bar can be a nutrient-dense treat that doesn’t deserve the same classification.

When choosing chocolate, it’s important to read the ingredient labels carefully. The fewer additives and the higher the cocoa content, the better the chocolate aligns with your health goals. Curious about how to spot hidden additives in your food? Check out Noom’s guide on reading nutrition labels for tips on making smarter choices while grocery shopping!

Can chocolate fit into your weight loss plan? With Noom, it can!

Chocolate is not off-limits if you aim for a balanced and healthy diet. The potential benefits—such as improved heart health, better mood, and even appetite regulation—make dark chocolate a worthwhile addition to a well-rounded diet. Still, it’s important to be mindful of portion sizes and overall calorie intake. You can enjoy the flavor and potential health perks by choosing high-quality dark chocolate with minimal ingredients and avoiding ultra-processed chocolate-flavored products.

Ultimately, chocolate can be part of a sustainable, flexible approach to healthy eating—it’s all about balance. Whether you reach for a square of 85% dark chocolate or savor some milk chocolate, the key is mindful enjoyment. By making intentional choices and understanding the differences between chocolate varieties, you can fully embrace this beloved treat while prioritizing your health and weight-loss goals.

Fill out our questionnaire to see how Noom can support you in reaching your goals, chocolate included!